Scilly Cay is a privately-owned island in Anguilla, renowned for its relaxed beach setting and vibrant atmosphere. Guests are transported via a complimentary boat service. The island specializes in grilled seafood, particularly lobster and crayfish, alongside chicken options. Live music and potent rum punch contribute to a festive ambiance. While celebrated for its unique experience, visitor feedback indicates a range of experiences, from idyllic to disappointing, often tied to cost and service.